Trust Me, I'm in Business: Why Building Trust Is Everything (And Why Most People Get It Wrong)

Related Articles:

• The Old Reader Profile
• Professional Development Skills

The bloke sitting across from me at the café yesterday was complaining about his staff. Again. "They just don't trust me," he whined between sips of his overpriced flat white. I wanted to tell him the truth – that trust isn't something you demand, it's something you bloody well earn. But instead, I nodded politely and thought about the 15 years I've spent watching businesses rise and fall based on this one critical factor.

Trust is the difference between a thriving workplace and a toxic wasteland. Full stop.

Here's what gets me fired up: everyone thinks they know how to build trust, but most business leaders are doing it completely backwards. They focus on the grand gestures, the team-building retreats in the Blue Mountains, the expensive consultants who come in spouting corporate buzzwords. Meanwhile, they're missing the daily micro-interactions that actually matter.

I learned this the hard way back in 2009 when I was managing a team of 12 in Perth. Thought I was the bee's knees because I had an open-door policy and bought pizza for the office every Friday. Then one of my best performers resigned without notice. During her exit interview, she told me something that still makes me cringe: "Andrew, you say you trust us, but you check our work three times before it goes out. You say we can make decisions, but you override us constantly."

Ouch.

The Trust Paradox Most Leaders Don't Understand

Here's where it gets interesting – and where 73% of managers completely miss the mark. Trust isn't built through words; it's built through consistent actions that demonstrate vulnerability and respect. The leaders who understand this create environments where people actually want to show up, not just physically, but mentally and emotionally.

Take Canva, for example. Their leadership team regularly admits when they don't know something and asks for help from their staff. Revolutionary? Hardly. But it works because it shows they trust their team's expertise. Compare that to the traditional command-and-control approach where admitting ignorance is seen as weakness.

The problem is most Australian businesses are still stuck in the 1980s mentality where the boss knows best and questioning authority is insubordination. I've seen this mindset destroy teams faster than you can say "restructure."

What Actually Works (And What Definitely Doesn't)

Building genuine trust requires three things that most people find uncomfortable:

Transparency beyond comfort zones. This means sharing information you'd rather keep close to your chest. Budget challenges, strategic concerns, even personal struggles that affect your work. I'm not saying overshare your marital problems, but if you're stressed about a major client potentially leaving, your team probably already knows something's up.

Admitting when you're wrong. And I mean really wrong, not just "mistakes were made" corporate speak. Last year, I pushed our Brisbane office to implement a new system that turned out to be a complete disaster. Instead of trying to spin it, I called a team meeting and said, "I stuffed up. This was my decision, it's not working, and we're going back to the old system while I figure out something better."

Following through on commitments, especially the small ones. If you say you'll get back to someone by Friday, do it by Thursday. If you promise to look into a policy change, actually look into it. These tiny moments build or erode trust faster than any grand gesture.

The thing that drives me mental is watching leaders who think they can fake trust. You know the type – they use phrases like "my team" possessively, delegate tasks but not authority, and wonder why their staff seem disengaged during meetings.

The Melbourne Coffee Shop Revelation

Six months ago, I was in Melbourne (shock horror, a Sydney-sider admitting Melbourne has good coffee) when I witnessed something that perfectly illustrated effective trust-building. The café owner was training a new barista, and instead of hovering and correcting every move, she said, "I'm going to let you handle the next ten customers completely on your own. Make mistakes, learn from them, and call me only if someone's genuinely unhappy."

The young barista looked terrified but also energised. She made several small errors, but customers were patient because they could see she was learning, not being micromanaged. By the end of the morning, she was moving with confidence.

That's what trust looks like in action. Not perfect performance, but the space to grow within clear boundaries.

The Trust Multiplier Effect

Here's what most business owners don't realise: trust is multiplicative, not additive. When you trust one person publicly, others notice. When you follow through on commitments consistently, word spreads. When you admit mistakes without making excuses, people start believing you'll handle their mistakes with the same maturity.

I've seen teams transform when leaders embrace this principle. Productivity increases, yes, but more importantly, creativity flourishes. People start bringing ideas instead of just following instructions. They solve problems before you even know problems exist.

The financial impact is substantial too. Companies with high-trust cultures report 47% higher revenue growth and 40% lower turnover. But honestly, even without the statistics, you can feel the difference when you walk into a high-trust workplace. There's energy there. People make eye contact. Conversations happen naturally instead of in scheduled meetings.

The Uncomfortable Truth About Vulnerability

Most Australian business leaders, particularly blokes my age, struggle with vulnerability. We were raised on the idea that showing weakness invites attack. But in modern workplaces, the opposite is true. Leadership skills for supervisors have evolved dramatically, and vulnerability is now recognised as a core strength.

I remember watching a CEO in Adelaide break down during a company meeting while discussing redundancies. He didn't try to hide his emotion or maintain professional detachment. He said, "This is the hardest thing I've ever had to do, and I'm sorry." The room was silent, but not uncomfortable. It was honest.

That moment of authenticity built more trust than years of polished presentations ever could.

Why Some People Will Hate This Approach

Not everyone will appreciate leaders who prioritise trust-building. Some employees prefer clear hierarchies and defined roles. Some stakeholders want confident certainty, even when that certainty is manufactured. Some board members see vulnerability as incompetence.

These people are wrong, but they're loud about being wrong.

The reality is that building trust requires patience and consistency that many leaders find frustrating. You can't measure trust with quarterly reports or productivity metrics. You can't fast-track it with expensive training programmes. You certainly can't buy it with better benefits packages.

The Simple Daily Practices That Actually Matter

Forget the complicated frameworks and assessment tools. Trust is built through mundane, consistent behaviours:

Returning phone calls when you say you will. Remembering names and personal details. Asking for input before making decisions that affect people. Explaining the 'why' behind policies and changes. Celebrating others' successes without taking credit.

It's also about the employee supervision approach you take – are you supervising to catch mistakes or to develop capability? The difference in mindset creates completely different workplace cultures.

Most importantly, it's about consistency over time. Trust isn't built in moments of crisis; it's built in hundreds of small interactions when nothing dramatic is happening.

The bloke from the café yesterday? He's probably still wondering why his staff don't trust him while he continues the same behaviours that created the problem in the first place. Trust takes time to build and seconds to destroy, but rebuilding it? That's the work of months or years.

And frankly, not every leader has the patience for that kind of long-term thinking.

But the ones who do? They're building businesses that actually last.